Pastry Made Reviews

Pastry Made has an overall rating of 4.9 based on 97 reviews. Customer feedback on Pastry Made is mixed: Pastry Made reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality ingredients, delicious flavors, beautiful presentation, excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to food enthusiasts, gift shoppers, event planners, dessert lovers. However, Pastry Made is often criticized for its higher price point, limited delivery options, occasional shipping delays, small product variety.

4.9/5.0

97 reviews

5 Stars

93

4 Stars

7

3 Stars

0

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Pastry Made Reviews (97)
Arlene.Mendoza
January 28, 2023
"Another Great Experience!"
Just placed my second order (to the USA) and it was just as fantastic as the first one. Both came with over 5 pins, and I’m definitely gonna order again. The pins are sturdy, top-notch quality, roll like a dream, and the range of designs makes them awesome gifts. The tiny recipe book has some delightful cookie recipes (around 10). Totally worth the price. My orders showed up in about one to three weeks. It’s a lovely way to bake with the kiddos! They get super pumped.
MichaelMartinez
January 21, 2023
"Just got my hands on two Pastrymade rolling pins..."
I just got my hands on two Pastrymade rolling pins for Christmas, and they’re fantastic. Like many carved pins, they’re a tad smaller than regular ones, which makes it super easy to maneuver on cookie dough. I adore them and they make the cutest biscuits. I’ll surely grab some more designs. The shipping and tracking were spot on with FedEx. There were some delays, but hey, it was December, so that’s totally understandable. It’s a solid product and I love supporting a small family business.
lazybird285
January 21, 2023
"Awesome Rolling Pins"
I tried out my first couple of pins for baking Christmas cookies and I was completely sold! These pins are super user-friendly and they create beautiful cookies. I quickly placed an order for three additional pins, which took a little while to get here, but it was definitely worth it. I highly suggest these rolling pins with stunning designs. Just stick to the instructions on how to use 'em and you won't be let down.
TraceyReyes
January 20, 2023
"Received three rolling pins and they were all..."
I got three rolling pins and they were all beautifully crafted. Not a single flaw. The shipping was really quick to my place in Wisconsin, took under a week. Awesome company.
ClaudeBryant
January 17, 2023
"My Rolling Pin Order Post-Christmas"
After Christmas, I placed an order for a rolling pin, and a few weeks went by with it still showing as waiting to ship from FedEx. I reached out to the seller, and just a few hours later, I got an update from FedEx saying they had my item and it was on its way. Within four days, my rolling pin arrived! Talk about GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!! Huge thanks! The rolling pin is stunning, and I’m super excited to give it a go!!!! I might just start browsing for my next purchase now!!!
GeneMontgomery
January 16, 2023
"An Amazing Purchase"
I got myself six of those embossed rolling pins for Christmas gifts. The first batch showed up right on time, while the second one took a bit longer, but you know what? They were totally worth the wait. The designs are just lovely. Everyone who got a pin was super pleased to receive it! I'm really into the mission behind Pastrymade. Thanks a bunch, and I hope you keep thriving!
IsobelKennedy
January 15, 2023
"Absolutely Gorgeous Rolling Pins!"
I really appreciate the stunning rolling pins! I don’t bake much, but when I do, I want it to feel special. These rolling pins are just what I needed. I’m excited to use them with that butter cookie recipe you included. Thanks a ton, and I'm sending you my best wishes!
Kirk.Lynch
January 11, 2023
"My Experience with the Rolling Pins Order"
I placed an order for the rolling pins back in November to show my support for the folks in Ukraine. I intended them as a unique Christmas present for my daughters and daughters-in-law, who are all young moms with little bakers. I was a bit let down to find just one recipe sheet and three brushes for four rolling pins! Guess I'll have to figure it out myself! Overall, even though the pins showed up on January 10, 2023, I'm pleased with their quality and really hope the results turn out as beautiful as the pins themselves!

Sure, my order was late, so it didn’t make it in time for Christmas. But I really don’t think the production issue that Pastrymade mentioned will happen again. The product is definitely worth a little wait.
ToddNichols
January 11, 2023
"A Satisfying Resolution"
I placed an order for the Joyeux Noel pin on December 8th, and I was really counting on it arriving in time for my Christmas Eve cookie prep, based on what the website said about delivery times. Sadly, that didn’t happen, and I got pretty annoyed since I wasn’t getting any replies to my emails. Then, Karolina stepped in and took charge of the situation. She clarified that there’s a processing period for crafting orders, especially since they had a ton of orders in December and couldn’t respond to all the emails. She was super nice and did everything she could to make up for the delay and put a smile on my face! Eventually, the pins arrived, and they’re beautifully made. I still need to practice a bit, but I’m already smitten with them. I really admire the effort that goes into Karolina's family business, and I’d just suggest that potential buyers keep in mind that delivery might take a little while.
JerryJackson
January 10, 2023
"Definitely worth a little patience."
The two pins I got for my wife are just beautiful! She’s super happy and can’t wait to start baking cookies.

Sure, my order took longer than expected, so it didn’t arrive in time for Christmas. But I really don’t think the production issue that Pastrymade mentioned will happen again. Honestly, this product is absolutely worth a little wait.
EdgarWilliamson
January 10, 2023
"Well-crafted item"
This well-crafted item really surpassed what I was hoping for, and I'm super excited to try out the three pins I bought. Big thanks to the crew at Pastrymade!
blueleopard604
January 09, 2023
"Order from NZ arrived after 3 weeks"
I placed my order online on December 18 and honestly didn’t think it would show up in time for Christmas 2022. The payment went through fast. The video update about the delay wasn’t really useful, so I shot them an email suggesting they post it on Facebook, but I didn’t hear back until I followed up there. The FedEx tracking info was handy for keeping tabs on my shipment. My order came in two parts, with the last one arriving on January 9, 2023.
redcat363
January 08, 2023
"Awesome Item"
This product is really well constructed, showcasing excellent craftsmanship. I'm a big fan of the different styles and options available. The pricing is quite reasonable too. It's super user-friendly.
magdalene.wisniewska
January 07, 2023
"Karolina Goes the Extra Mile for Her Customers"
UPDATE: I got a message back from the owner of Pastry Made. She tackled my issues head-on and sincerely apologized for the hold-up. She mentioned that my pins are all set to ship, but also offered to cancel my order if I didn’t want to wait. I’m still super pumped to get these, so I decided to stick with the order. I’ve confirmed that shipping is underway since she gave me the tracking number. I’m really pleased with how Karolina handled everything; she truly went above and beyond to make sure I’m happy. I really appreciate her response.
whitezebra133
January 04, 2023
"Have Faith in Your Artisan ❤️"
The first time I visited this place, I was just trying to check out as many reviews as possible, especially the negative ones, 'cause honestly, I was a bit nervous. I feared it might be a scam, but you all helped me see things differently. I placed an order for two rolling pins on December 9th, hoping to get them by Christmas, but there were some shipping delays. Karolina even sent me a video message about it. Now that I have my pins, they are absolutely GORGEOUS, alright? The engraving is so detailed that I'm blown away. Even the Christmas gifts are crafted beautifully!
Pastrymade is a small business, powered by the dedication of a team of artisans, and I truly admire that. The truth is, we’ve all become accustomed to super-fast online shopping that often sells low-quality items and takes advantage of workers. So when a company takes its time to do things right, we tend to get upset and suspect a scam.
Pastrymade stands out in this landscape, and I’m all in for supporting them from here on out.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Pastry Made?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.